Using Medical Records as Evidence: Health Conditions and Living Conditions

In personal injury cases, medical records play a crucial role in establishing a link between a plaintiff’s health conditions and the conditions they have endured due to someone else’s negligence. This evidence helps quantify the impact of the injury and the subsequent medical treatments, making it a pivotal element in determining compensation. Here, we delve into how medical records are used as evidence, particularly when health conditions are connected to living conditions.

Establishing Causation

Medical records serve as a factual record of a person’s health status before and after an accident. They are essential for establishing a causal relationship between the incident and the injuries. For instance, in a slip and fall case where someone sustains a spinal injury, the medical records would detail the patient’s pre-accident spinal condition and post-accident diagnosis and treatment. This documentation helps establish that the accident directly caused the injury.

Quantifying Damages

Medical records provide concrete information regarding the extent of injuries and the treatment required. This allows for a quantification of damages, encompassing both economic and non-economic losses. For example, if a person suffers a traumatic brain injury in a car accident, their medical records would document the initial diagnosis, treatment plan, and long-term prognosis. This information is crucial for determining the compensation needed for ongoing medical care, rehabilitation, and the impact on their quality of life.

Linking Health Conditions to Living Conditions

In some personal injury cases, health conditions may be linked to subpar living conditions, such as exposure to toxic substances, mold, or unsafe premises. In these situations, medical records serve a dual purpose. They establish the existence of the health condition and provide evidence connecting it to the inadequate living conditions.

For instance, in a case involving toxic mold exposure in a rental property, the plaintiff’s medical records would contain details about respiratory issues or allergies. These records can be used alongside expert testimonies to demonstrate that the health condition resulted from the mold infestation, which the landlord neglected to address.

Ensuring Admissibility

To ensure the admissibility of medical records as evidence, they must meet certain criteria. They should be:

Relevant: The records should pertain to the injuries or health conditions in question.

Authentic: They must be genuine and accurately reflect the patient’s medical history and treatment.

Trustworthy: The records should be created in the ordinary course of business by healthcare providers.

Clear and Understandable: They should be clear and understandable to the court and jury.

Share Post